Re: Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon)

Wed Apr 15, 2020 12:54 am

Chris Mclean wrote:

Dee Dee wrote:

Don Jalapeno wrote:Ez ggs my dudes Cannonbolt + Chris Mclean are mafia, and Weevilunderwood is poisoner, im vt and everyone else too ggs
Im interested in how u derived that scumread in early d1. W0W
Lynch Dee Dee

^ Lol its rather funny to get sred for saying 3 random people are a role, as an opening message, when i am the second/third person to talk ahaha omg so funny haha

Don Jalapeno wrote:Hm yeah. For now i'll stick to my Dee Dee lynch since how they gave reads early day one without explaining them at all is scummy

^hahaha omg haha wow i didnt explain my srs wow haha almost like they hadnt even talked yet haha, why are you not going for everyone else who placed a lynch without explaining it? Hypocrisy hahaha omg haha

Don Jalapeno wrote:Kk by PoE, Tee Dee is scum

Don Jalapeno wrote:because 1) Greg Universe is like highly unlikely to be scum
2)Same thing goes for Tinky Winky cause scum would obviously not help town by working their ass off to form those thesis
3) Tee Dee posted a whole block of reads early d1 as i said without explaining them a bit
4) Hugh Test is null
5) Rest are basically not talking at all. If tee dee flips scum then cannon bolt is scum too since cannon bold were their scumread but Tee Dee didn't lynch them and instead went for Hugh Test (If tee dee flips scum hugh test is clear from my PoV)

^ lol Greg is not highly unlikely to be scum, just because he sent a couple messages discussing the same thing over and over with you means nothing
2) Scum would "town" to get that exact responsse from town people like you who cant see effort without thinking "wow he must be town!!"
3) hahahahaha bro so funny
4) Hugh Test is actually your mafia partner

Unlynch Chris Mclean
Lynch Don Jalapeno

hahahhahaa omg can you speak like an actual person and use original arguments instead of just copying what other people have said to try to get free towncred thx. As for the bits I highlighted in orange, they speak for themselves. Thanks. Now, I would sr this, but I sr Don more and I don't currently read Tee Dee and Don as scumpartners, but I'll reassess this when Don flips.

lol you can call it copying but none of what i said is for towncred nor did it get me any, i wont change what i have to say just because it was already said, the hugh test + don connection is from

Hugh Test wrote:i have no idea what my pfp will look like but considering the cursed childhood wants to kill me so i prolly am cursed as well

anyway Lynch Don Jalepeno

i'll check this thread tmrw my time so see if it's anymore active but for now

Hugh Test wrote:

Greg Universe wrote:

Kliff wrote:Stay active Fam

I felt that

mood

anyway so this just turned into a 2 person convo real quick. poisoner imo shouldn't claim d2 i don't see how town would benefit from that, fact is outside of maybe lylo i don't see a situation where we want poisoner to claim cuz then they just get brainshocked by maf.

in the meantime [b]unlynch don jalepeno[/b] they've been active so i'll just hop off cuz they haven't done anything scummy so far [strike]saying that no one has cuz barely anyone has talked, including me yes i am a hypocrite[/quote]

Don Jalapeno wrote:because 1) Greg Universe is like highly unlikely to be scum
2)Same thing goes for Tinky Winky cause scum would obviously not help town by working their ass off to form those thesis
3) Tee Dee posted a whole block of reads early d1 as i said without explaining them a bit
4) Hugh Test is null
5) Rest are basically not talking at all. If tee dee flips scum then cannon bolt is scum too since cannon bold were their scumread but Tee Dee didn't lynch them and instead went for Hugh Test (If tee dee flips scum hugh test is clear from my PoV)

This supposed rvs from Test to Jalapeno is so clearly fake, lynches him early, Don Literally ignores the lynch and doesnt mention Hugh or the lynch even once until he is unlynched to call him a null. The lynch accomplishes nothing, no pressure, no thought, no follow up. In fact it would seem like the only reasson to unlynch Don there was to simply not have 2 votes on him. Why would Hugh Test say Don had not done anything scummy (which he had) then unlynch, call people out for lurking, then NOT LYNCH ANYONE OR SAY ANYTHING MEANINGFUL?????????? hahah iss epic

Wed Apr 15, 2020 1:19 am

imo if don flips scum and i hold in my heart he will, there are two obvious partners which are hugh for what i said and then cannonbolt for the lynch on me, i sincerely doubt chris would bus day on what was at the time just 2 lynches when he lynched. I also disagree with what weevil and others have said about not lynching people who are talking because for one its stupid lol why would i not lynch my sr instead of a gamble on an inactive person, and second the game is really short, we cant just waste day 1 on a fucking inac slot because come day 2 we gain nothing and we are fucked because instead of looking for pieces to tie to what people have done in the game and how the lynches went we would instead be playing a pseudo day 1 where all we have is maybe a fearkill and trying to look for poisoner softs if they decide to even do that. Its just not a good play. If Don by some hellish reason is town then i would have to read back on wtf is happening becausse it makes no sense for him to be town and look for more subtle things, i also imagine i would get a lot of srs on me if he was town but that would be dumb given my sr on him is not just random pushing or malicious, from page 1 to here he has just posted absolute bullshit and gotten away with it lol my read on him is justified and more people should be on him imo

Wed Apr 15, 2020 5:15 am

Ok that puts a big tl on Dee Dee because those reads are nice and fair enough.
~~However, I think Vee Vee abd Tee Dee are conf scum at this point~~

Wed Apr 15, 2020 5:17 am

I'd suggest to the poisoner that they poison cannonbolt, and tomorrow would then probably be a Hugh Test lynch.

Wed Apr 15, 2020 8:43 am

Deadline! That concludes day 1

Final Vote Count 1.2

Like a Star @ heaven

Dee Dee (2) -

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 2011

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 2211

Cannonbolt (0) -

Weevil Underwood (0) -

Hugh Test (1) -

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 2411

Tinky Winky (0) -

Don Jalapeno (3*) -

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 1711

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 2312

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 2111

Chris Mclean (1) -

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 1911

Greg Universe(0) -

Not Lynching- 1

Game 2: Custom Poisoner Open Setup (Preseaon) - Page 5 1811

was lynched and he was:

Don's Role:

It is Night 1, You have 24 hours to Send any night actions or idles in discord or on here. The Deadline will be April 16th at 8:30am EST

Hugh Test Would likely be subbed or significantly warned due to no making the posting requirements

Stay active Fam

Thu Apr 16, 2020 8:57 am

Day 2 Commence

Plurality applies, Hammer:4. If the hammer is Reach before Deadline, Night Phase Will begin.

Vote Count 2.0

Like a Star @ heaven

Dee Dee (0) -

Cannonbolt (0) -

Weevil Underwood (0) -

Hugh Test (0) -

Tinky Winky (0) -

Greg Universe(0) -

Not Lynching- 6

Chris Mclean has died last night he was:

Chris Role:

Deadline Will begin after the 7th post

Stay active Fam

Thu Apr 16, 2020 9:21 am

Hugh Test #1 has been subbed out, a new person is now using their account

Thu Apr 16, 2020 10:42 am

Wait, did poisoner really idle? cause that means this is mylo, no?

Thu Apr 16, 2020 12:14 pm

lynch cannonbolt

Thu Apr 16, 2020 9:15 pm

Tinky Winky wrote:Wait, did poisoner really idle? cause that means this is mylo, no?

huh?

Thu Apr 16, 2020 11:07 pm

I expected a lot more activity than what is going on right now Neutral

My thought process is this is a fearkill by cannonbolt or Hugh test, since the setup is already so small you might as well kill the one person who has sred you since half day. Layer 2 of that is someone like Weevil/Greg/Tinky killing chris to misdirect attention to them and get someone who shows attention/effort out of the game. For now i Stick with cannonbolt as mafia, he mightve just thought chris was poisoner from chris;s last message and tried to kill him to avoid his own death, we will see

Thu Apr 16, 2020 11:58 pm

I thought that poisoned person gets publicly revealed?

Fri Apr 17, 2020 1:02 am

Tinky Winky wrote:Wait, did poisoner really idle? cause that means this is mylo, no?

where did this piece of info come from

Fri Apr 17, 2020 1:02 am

Tinky Winky wrote:I thought that poisoned person gets publicly revealed?

squint

Fri Apr 17, 2020 1:04 am

Dee Dee wrote:I expected a lot more activity than what is going on right now
My thought process is this is a fearkill by cannonbolt or Hugh test, since the setup is already so small you might as well kill the one person who has sred you since half day. Layer 2 of that is someone like Weevil/Greg/Tinky killing chris to misdirect attention to them and get someone who shows attention/effort out of the game. For now i Stick with cannonbolt as mafia, he mightve just thought chris was poisoner from chris;s last message and tried to kill him to avoid his own death, we will see

first half of the post is raw wifom, try again for a dollar bbcakes
I don't believe killing the poisoner actually stop them from using their poison anyways? shud probably get host confirmation on that one though ig
@bluegummybear

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:01 am

Tinky Winky wrote:Wait, did poisoner really idle? cause that means this is mylo, no?

Unless I'm wrong, it really seems like it

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:07 am

Dee Dee wrote:I expected a lot more activity than what is going on right now
My thought process is this is a fearkill by cannonbolt or Hugh test, since the setup is already so small you might as well kill the one person who has sred you since half day. Layer 2 of that is someone like Weevil/Greg/Tinky killing chris to misdirect attention to them and get someone who shows attention/effort out of the game. For now i Stick with cannonbolt as mafia, he mightve just thought chris was poisoner from chris;s last message and tried to kill him to avoid his own death, we will see

There's a really iffy tone in his lines but I can't exactly point it out, whist I also don't completely agree with your points either; Chris was the most TR'd person by the end of day one, your first thoughts would mostly always be to kill that person
And Chris' "I'd suggest to the poisoner that they poison cannonbolt" isn't exactly indicative of him being the poisoner?

I haven't completely read everything dee dee said last day (sorry been slightly busy, fam's bdays and stuff) but so far I don't think this slot is scum, I like the fact that they're confidently stating their reads and all, but I can't say I agree with all of them

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:08 am

Cannonbolt wrote:

Tinky Winky wrote:Wait, did poisoner really idle? cause that means this is mylo, no?

where did this piece of info come from

From the fact that it is 4v2 right now, and poisoner has seriously messed things up

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:10 am

Cannonbolt wrote:

Dee Dee wrote:I expected a lot more activity than what is going on right now
My thought process is this is a fearkill by cannonbolt or Hugh test, since the setup is already so small you might as well kill the one person who has sred you since half day. Layer 2 of that is someone like Weevil/Greg/Tinky killing chris to misdirect attention to them and get someone who shows attention/effort out of the game. For now i Stick with cannonbolt as mafia, he mightve just thought chris was poisoner from chris;s last message and tried to kill him to avoid his own death, we will see

first half of the post is raw wifom, try again for a dollar bbcakes
I don't believe killing the poisoner actually stop them from using their poison anyways? shud probably get host confirmation on that one though ig
@bluegummybear

It stops the kill, as it says in the role information
And so far I've liked the cannobolt slot, not sure which of deedee/cannonbolt do I prefer, both of them have stated their reads pretty confidently and are actively scumhunting, though have a gut feeling that one of them is scum

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:12 am

I'm leaning towards a Tinky Winky lynch, though I swear to god if either of Weevil/Hugh Test are scum because both of them have done and said jack and there's literally nothing I can read and offer my opinions from

@Hugh Test how's your day been?

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:13 am

Cannonbolt wrote:

Tinky Winky wrote:I thought that poisoned person gets publicly revealed?

squint

Also, has there been a poison? I seriously seem to have missed it, what do you mean squint?

Fri Apr 17, 2020 5:15 am

@Tinky Winky who exactly are you leaning on rn? We know about your reads as much as we know about the core of pluto

Fri Apr 17, 2020 10:29 am

Plurality applies, Hammer:4. If the hammer is Reach before Deadline, Night Phase Will begin. You will now have 72 hours left by the time this post was created. Deadline Will Be at Monday 10:30 am EST. Use your time wisely and productively

Vote Count 2.1

Like a Star @ heaven

Dee Dee (0) -

Cannonbolt (1*) -

Weevil Underwood (0) -

Hugh Test (0) -

Tinky Winky (0) -

Greg Universe(0) -

No Lynch (0)-

Not Lynching- 5

Stay active Fam

Fri Apr 17, 2020 10:42 am

Usually we don't No Lynch just because it's MyLo

HOWEVER

that's because the towniest player just gets NKed anyways.

This gamestate however, doesn't have a towniest player.

Hence, No Lynch

Fri Apr 17, 2020 11:29 am

I actually have to agree with Cannonbolt/Greg here on Dee Dee's line of thinking. Anyone could have seen the Chris kill, and whether that was a fear kill or mafia trying to hide it under the pretense of a fear kill is up for anyone's guess.

Also, yes this is mylo. Let's not lynch anyone willynilly unless we are 100% confident they are mafioso. In the case that we do nl, which does give us a stronger chance of lynching mafia, poisoner should claim after poisoning on n2.

I want to point the attention to those people who were on vanity lynches on d1. That's right, I'm looking at you @Greg Universe and @Weevil Underwood (I'll give Hugh Test a second chance to redeem themselves because they got subbed)
Can yall explain why you chose to stay under Chris Mclean and Hugh Test respectively when there really weren't much indication that they were mafioso?