Game 1AAA: Semi-Open Setup (Preseaon)

Also I claim OS Day Vigilante, just because the chances of a doctor are pretty high

Gumball Watterson wrote:Also I claim OS Day Vigilante, just because the chances of a doctor are pretty high

yikes idk how i feel about this claim decision

Darwin Watterson wrote:

Gumball Watterson wrote:Also I claim OS Day Vigilante, just because the chances of a doctor are pretty high

yikes idk how i feel about this claim decision

Dw about it. I'm not expecting any special treatment

FYI gumball you just implied that you were the lesser brother because gumball is a cat, Darwin is a goldfish, and you just lynched a cat.

Also on a more serious note I townlean Darwin now because of this:

Darwin Watterson wrote:@nibbles allegations that we are scum brothers as well?preposterous

Scum typically does not go so over the top because it draws attention to them. Everyone else is, of course, null atm because they haven't come on yet, and so for now I'll stick to my lynch because there's no real reason not to yet.

Oh now you claimed

Nibbles wrote:FYI gumball you just implied that you were the lesser brother because gumball is a cat, Darwin is a goldfish, and you just lynched a cat.

Also on a more serious note I townlean Darwin now because of this:

Darwin Watterson wrote:@nibbles allegations that we are scum brothers as well?preposterous

Scum typically does not go so over the top because it draws attention to them. Everyone else is, of course, null atm because they haven't come on yet, and so for now I'll stick to my lynch because there's no real reason not to yet.

ty i appreciate this becuz i am indeed in fact town

Nibbles wrote:FYI gumball you just implied that you were the lesser brother because gumball is a cat, Darwin is a goldfish, and you just lynched a cat.

Also on a more serious note I townlean Darwin now because of this:

Darwin Watterson wrote:@nibbles allegations that we are scum brothers as well?preposterous

Scum typically does not go so over the top because it draws attention to them. Everyone else is, of course, null atm because they haven't come on yet, and so for now I'll stick to my lynch because there's no real reason not to yet.

I don't really get that first part but w/e

Anyways Re: bolded part
You can't really expect much to come from a day 1 reaction. Although I know you said town lean as opposed to town read, I still want you to keep in mind that a read based on that is usually more based on playermeta. (Ofc there is no pmeta so I'm just telling you to think twice about your read)

Gumball Watterson wrote:

Nibbles wrote:FYI gumball you just implied that you were the lesser brother because gumball is a cat, Darwin is a goldfish, and you just lynched a cat.

Also on a more serious note I townlean Darwin now because of this:

Darwin Watterson wrote:@nibbles allegations that we are scum brothers as well?preposterous

Scum typically does not go so over the top because it draws attention to them. Everyone else is, of course, null atm because they haven't come on yet, and so for now I'll stick to my lynch because there's no real reason not to yet.

I don't really get that first part but w/e

Anyways Re: bolded part
You can't really expect much to come from a day 1 reaction. Although I know you said town lean as opposed to town read, I still want you to keep in mind that a read based on that is usually more based on playermeta. (Ofc there is no pmeta so I'm just telling you to think twice about your read)

i mean isnt it obvious im town

Darwin Watterson wrote:

Gumball Watterson wrote:

Nibbles wrote:FYI gumball you just implied that you were the lesser brother because gumball is a cat, Darwin is a goldfish, and you just lynched a cat.

Also on a more serious note I townlean Darwin now because of this:

Darwin Watterson wrote:@nibbles allegations that we are scum brothers as well?preposterous

Scum typically does not go so over the top because it draws attention to them. Everyone else is, of course, null atm because they haven't come on yet, and so for now I'll stick to my lynch because there's no real reason not to yet.

I don't really get that first part but w/e

Anyways Re: bolded part
You can't really expect much to come from a day 1 reaction. Although I know you said town lean as opposed to town read, I still want you to keep in mind that a read based on that is usually more based on playermeta. (Ofc there is no pmeta so I'm just telling you to think twice about your read)

i mean isnt it obvious im town

Is it?

I mean, now we can at least conf your role to not be a lie (but there's no reason for scum to fakeclaim their role in this setup so it doesn't matter).
On another note, I'm thinking that that could be one of the following:
Scum reacting badly to pressure and thinking role claim actually gives them towncred
Town reacting badly to pressure and thinking role claim actually gives them towncred
Scum wanting me to be scared of their shot so that I ul
Something else weird that I haven't thought of (Do say if you see anything I've missed)

Gumball Watterson wrote:

Darwin Watterson wrote:

Gumball Watterson wrote:

Nibbles wrote:FYI gumball you just implied that you were the lesser brother because gumball is a cat, Darwin is a goldfish, and you just lynched a cat.

Also on a more serious note I townlean Darwin now because of this:

Darwin Watterson wrote:@nibbles allegations that we are scum brothers as well?preposterous

Scum typically does not go so over the top because it draws attention to them. Everyone else is, of course, null atm because they haven't come on yet, and so for now I'll stick to my lynch because there's no real reason not to yet.

I don't really get that first part but w/e

Anyways Re: bolded part
You can't really expect much to come from a day 1 reaction. Although I know you said town lean as opposed to town read, I still want you to keep in mind that a read based on that is usually more based on playermeta. (Ofc there is no pmeta so I'm just telling you to think twice about your read)

i mean isnt it obvious im town

Is it?

yes and for those wondering i am going to quote everything even if im replying to the tinest part

Nibbles wrote:I mean, now we can at least conf your role to not be a lie (but there's no reason for scum to fakeclaim their role in this setup so it doesn't matter).
On another note, I'm thinking that that could be one of the following:
Scum reacting badly to pressure and thinking role claim actually gives them towncred
Town reacting badly to pressure and thinking role claim actually gives them towncred
Scum wanting me to be scared of their shot so that I ul
Something else weird that I haven't thought of (Do say if you see anything I've missed)

The claim wasn't in response to you. It was supposed to be my first message actually, but I forgot to put it first.

There is certainly use of d1 reactions. Just as much use as any other day's reactions. Scumreading doesn't start day 2, else d1 would be random. If d1 is random what's even the point of playing? There is a point. That is because it is possible to scumread d1. I think you saying you can't is a vain attempt at getting my reads ignored, which suggests that if you are scum then they are correct.

These things suggest to me that you are scum (undermining my reads) and that you are a good info flip too (because then we may have validation of what I have already said). I will therefore stick to my lynch and I suggest others hop on too.

I mean that makes the claim all the weirder gumball.

Nibbles wrote:There is certainly use of d1 reactions. Just as much use as any other day's reactions. Scumreading doesn't start day 2, else d1 would be random. If d1 is random what's even the point of playing? There is a point. That is because it is possible to scumread d1. I think you saying you can't is a vain attempt at getting my reads ignored, which suggests that if you are scum then they are correct.

These things suggest to me that you are scum (undermining my reads) and that you are a good info flip too (because then we may have validation of what I have already said). I will therefore stick to my lynch and I suggest others hop on too.

But uh
None of that really matters in this situation. I don't get why you went off at the sight of a claim

Gumball and Nibbles seem to be having BEEF. Sounds like opposite factions, but still day 1 so who knows.

I went off because I needed a bath :/
Also my arguments aren't based on your claim because it can easily be interpreted as either town or scum (so it's NAI). I'm pretty sure that they do matter too for the purposes of a) other players reading me based on what I say and, for me more importantly, b) showing other players why I think you are scum and hopefully convincing them that I am right, given that you are the most scummy person atm imo. So I would appreciate it if you stop just saying my reads don't matter and either tell me why you are town (not null as your arguments have been suggesting) or make reads of your own because unless I'm being stupid (and I wouldn't put it past myself), you haven't made any reads on anyone who has been online yet, but rather only defended yourself.

Moving on, Hi Larry. I like your pfp. Unless you sr or tr one of me or Gumball I would like you to explain why you thing it's SvT and not TvT. We're a cat and a mouse. There's no beef involved. Finally, saying 'who knows' is very unhelpful because you are undermining your thoughts. If you are town, don't be shy; tell us what you think and why you think it. Otherwise all you are is a vote and not a contributing member of town.

Wow there Nibbles, I see now it wasn't beef and you are simply overly aggressive with everyone. How about we take it down a few lol. I dont sr or tr neither of you atm, my comment was simply stating an observation i had at the moment. No need to be so hostile...

Nibbles wrote:I went off because I needed a bath :/
Also my arguments aren't based on your claim because it can easily be interpreted as either town or scum (so it's NAI). I'm pretty sure that they do matter too for the purposes of a) other players reading me based on what I say and, for me more importantly, b) showing other players why I think you are scum and hopefully convincing them that I am right, given that you are the most scummy person atm imo. So I would appreciate it if you stop just saying my reads don't matter and either tell me why you are town (not null as your arguments have been suggesting) or make reads of your own because unless I'm being stupid (and I wouldn't put it past myself), you haven't made any reads on anyone who has been online yet, but rather only defended yourself.

Moving on, Hi Larry. I like your pfp. Unless you sr or tr one of me or Gumball I would like you to explain why you thing it's SvT and not TvT. We're a cat and a mouse. There's no beef involved. Finally, saying 'who knows' is very unhelpful because you are undermining your thoughts. If you are town, don't be shy; tell us what you think and why you think it. Otherwise all you are is a vote and not a contributing member of town.

Tbh I think this is TvT as well and I'm not even sure why we're arguing

I think its weird that you are classifying it as tvt, sounds like you're trying to defend one of your scum partners...

Vote Count 1.1, Plurality applies, Hammer:5. If hammer is Reach before Deadline, Night Phase Will begin. You have 64 hours left by the time this post was created.





Gumball Watterson (1) -


Darwin Watterson (0) -

Tom Cat (1) -



Nibbles (0) -

Quacker (0) -

Jerry Mouse (0) -

Banana joe (0) -

Larry Needlemeyer (1) -

 

Darwin Watterson why you on me boy

vote Gumball Watterson
i think your claim has no reason to be fake, but claiming so early paired with your spew about tvt make you a good lynch.

Nibbles wrote:Imagine confirming in the wrong game thread

this is some mad shade

Vote Nibbles

Banana joe wrote:vote Gumball Watterson
i think your claim has no reason to be fake, but claiming so early paired with your spew about tvt make you a good lynch.

now this is garbage incarnate. I thought the game was still in RVS and posted without reading but I guess not.

Vote Banana Joe